Are Higher Taxes Inevitable? What Every Investor Should Know
financial commute

Are Higher Taxes Inevitable? What Every Investor Should Know

Are Higher Taxes Inevitable? What Every Investor Should Know

GO BACK
financial commute

‍

Featuring

Chris Galeski, Wealth Advisor and Partner, Morton Wealth

Beau Wirick, Director of Financial Planning, Morton Wealth

‍

Overview

The US national debt recently crossed $40 trillion. Everyone’s starting to ask: does that math eventually lead to higher taxes?

In this episode of Financial Commute, Chris Galeski sits down with Beau Wirick, Director of Financial Planning at Morton Wealth, to work through the actual mechanics of the debt problem, what history suggests about how governments resolve it, why inflation may be doing more of the work than explicit tax increases, and what investors can do right now to build tax diversification into their retirement strategy before the environment shifts.

‍

‍

Key Takeaways

  • The US debt problem is structural and the gap between spending and revenue is not closing on its own. In 2025, the federal government spent approximately $7 trillion and collected about $5.2 trillion in tax revenue. Of that spending, roughly $5 trillion is mandatory: Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, interest on the debt, and programs like SNAP. All discretionary spending, including defense and government operations, is effectively borrowed. The conclusion that some form of higher taxes is coming is, as Beau puts it, an easy one to reach.
  • Inflation is already functioning as a hidden tax, and it may be the more politically palatable solution. Chris makes the point that what you could buy for $75 five years ago now costs $100. That is effectively a 30 percent reduction in purchasing power. Governments throughout history have used inflation to pay back debt with cheaper dollars, and the current environment is consistent with that pattern. The implication for investors is that holding cash is not a neutral position: it is a slow loss of purchasing power.
  • The post-World War II period is the only comparable historical precedent, and it involved both high inflation and extremely high taxes. When the US debt-to-GDP ratio last reached current levels in the late 1940s, the top marginal tax rate was approximately 91 percent. It remained above 70 percent through the 1970s. Beau notes that by historical standards, today's tax rates are actually quite low. That context cuts both ways: it is a reason for optimism that taxes are manageable now, and a reason to take seriously the possibility that they rise from here.
  • Social Security is where tax increases are most likely to happen first. The Social Security trust fund, currently about $2.5 trillion, is projected to run out by approximately 2032. When it does, there will only be about $0.78 available for every dollar of benefits owed. The most likely legislative fixes are raising the retirement age, lifting or eliminating the income cap on Social Security contributions (currently around $184,500), and potentially applying Social Security taxes to investment income as Medicare already does. Each of these is effectively a tax increase on higher earners.
  • Tax diversification across account types is the most practical response available to investors today. Beau's core recommendation is to avoid having all retirement savings in a single tax bucket. If you have a mix of traditional 401k or IRA accounts, taxable brokerage accounts, and Roth accounts, you can essentially choose your tax bracket in retirement by controlling which accounts you draw from in any given year. Roth distributions do not affect taxable income, which makes them particularly useful for managing exposure to Medicare surcharges and Social Security taxation.
  • Roth conversions at the 24 percent bracket or below are worth considering seriously. Beau's rule of thumb: if a client is currently paying 24 percent federal taxes, that may be the lowest rate they pay for the rest of their lives. Converting traditional IRA money to a Roth at that rate, while paying taxes now, could look like a very good decision if tax rates rise significantly in coming decades. For clients in the 35 to 37 percent bracket, especially in California where state taxes add another 10 to 11 percent, the math is less clear and requires stronger conviction about future rates.
  • Owning real assets is the hedge against the inflation scenario. If the government chooses to inflate its way out of debt rather than raise taxes explicitly, the people who fare best are those who own assets: stocks, real estate, gold, and other things that tend to appreciate alongside inflation. Cash loses value in that environment. Chris puts it directly: you could wake up in a world where the S&P 500 is at 15,000 and a cup of coffee costs $35. The only protection is to own things that go up.

‍

Key Moments from this Episode

0:00 – Intro: are taxes actually going higher?

0:58 – The debt problem: $40 trillion and $2 trillion more added every year

2:41 – Mandatory vs. discretionary spending: why every other dollar is borrowed

3:11 – Inflation as the hidden tax: paying back debt with cheaper dollars

5:00 – The last time debt was this high: what happened after World War II

6:45 – Tax rates in historical context: we're actually better off than 40 years ago

7:32 – Social Security's trust fund runs out by 2033: what happens then

9:06 – Two ways to fix Social Security: raise the age or raise the cap

10:36 – Estate taxes, capital gains, and other levers politicians could pull

12:14 – How to protect yourself: build tax diversification into your retirement strategy

14:19 – Roth conversions: who they make sense for and who they don't

15:25 – Closing take: own real assets, prepare for inflation, and don't wait

‍

Questions This Episode Answers

Are taxes going to go up?

Almost certainly in some form, though the form matters. Beau's view is that given the gap between what the federal government spends and what it collects in tax revenue, some combination of higher taxes, benefit reductions, and inflationary pressure is essentially inevitable. The more politically viable near-term changes are likely to include lifting the Social Security income cap, raising the retirement age for benefits, and potentially applying Social Security taxes to investment income. Broad-based income tax increases are possible but require an act of Congress and face more resistance. Inflation, which functions as a hidden tax, may do much of the work regardless.

What is the Social Security income cap and what happens if it is lifted?

Currently, Social Security payroll taxes apply only to wages up to approximately $184,500. Income above that threshold is not subject to the Social Security tax. If Congress raises or eliminates that cap, everyone earning above the current limit would pay an additional 6.2 percent employee contribution (and employers would match it) on the additional income. Raising the cap to $300,000, for example, would meaningfully increase Social Security revenue without touching income tax rates. Beau and Chris both view this as one of the more politically feasible fixes precisely because it affects a relatively small percentage of workers and is therefore easier to vote for.

What is tax diversification in retirement and why does it matter?

Tax diversification means having retirement savings spread across accounts that are taxed differently: traditional 401k and IRA accounts where you pay taxes on withdrawals as ordinary income, taxable brokerage accounts where growth is taxed at capital gains rates, and Roth accounts where qualified withdrawals are completely tax-free. If all your retirement savings are in a traditional 401k, every dollar you withdraw in retirement is ordinary income, and you have no flexibility. With a mix of account types, you can structure withdrawals to control how much taxable income you report in any given year, which affects your tax bracket, Medicare premium surcharges, and how much of your Social Security is taxed.

Should I do a Roth conversion?

Beau's rule of thumb is that if you are currently in the 24 percent federal tax bracket or below, a Roth conversion is worth serious consideration. The reasoning is that 24 percent may be among the lowest tax rates you pay for the rest of your life, particularly if tax rates rise in response to the debt situation. Converting traditional IRA money to a Roth means paying taxes now at the current rate, but all future growth and qualified withdrawals are then tax-free. For clients in the 35 to 37 percent bracket, especially in California where state taxes add another 10 to 11 percent, the math requires more conviction about future rate increases before a conversion makes sense.

What is inflation's role in paying down the national debt?

When a government allows inflation to run above the interest rate on its debt, it effectively repays that debt with dollars that are worth less than the dollars it originally borrowed. This is sometimes called financial repression. It does not require any legislation, it is politically less visible than a tax increase, and it has historical precedent: the US used a combination of inflation and growth to reduce its debt-to-GDP ratio significantly after World War II. The downside for investors and savers is that cash loses purchasing power over time. The protection is owning assets, stocks, real estate, gold, and other things that tend to appreciate alongside or ahead of inflation.

What should I invest in if taxes and inflation are both going up?

Chris and Beau both point to real assets as the core protection against an inflationary environment: stocks, real estate, and gold. The logic is that these assets tend to appreciate in nominal terms as prices rise, whereas cash loses purchasing power. On the tax side, the advice is to build diversification across account types so that you have flexibility in retirement to control your taxable income. Putting everything into a traditional 401k maximizes your tax deduction today but concentrates all future withdrawals in a single high-tax bucket. Spreading across traditional, Roth, and taxable accounts gives you options.

‍

Why This Matters for Anyone Planning for Retirement in the Next Ten to Twenty Years

The decisions most investors make in their 40s and 50s about which accounts to contribute to, whether to do Roth conversions, and how to allocate assets will determine how much flexibility they have in retirement when the tax environment may look very different. This is not a conversation about predicting the future. It is about building a portfolio that holds up across a range of scenarios.

  • Pre-retirees in the 24 percent federal tax bracket or below who have not yet considered whether Roth conversions make sense given the current rate environment
  • Anyone with the majority of their retirement savings in a traditional 401k or IRA who wants to understand what tax diversification would look like and what options exist to build it

At Morton Wealth, retirement tax planning is built into every financial plan we run. If you want to understand how your current account mix positions you for a range of tax scenarios in retirement, that is exactly the analysis we can walk you through.

‍

Watch relevant content:

The Economic Signals We Can't Ignore & What to Do About Them

Is Your Retirement Account a Future Tax Bomb?

‍

Disclosures: Information presented herein is for discussion and illustrative purposes only and is not intended to constitute financial advice. The views and opinions expressed by the speakers are as of the date of the recording and are subject to change. These views are not intended as a recommendation to buy or sell any securities, and should not be relied on as financial, tax, or legal advice. You should consult with your financial professional, accountant, or tax professional before implementing any transactions or strategies concerning your finances.

‍